SFI Agroforestry frustrations

Like many others we have been involved with the ELMS Agroforestry trials and kept an eye on the launch of the SFI Agroforestry schemes.

It seemed like it would be of real interest to those of us growing walnuts (and other fruit/nut crops) and provide a real helping hand to get these types of sustainable and profitable crops established.

It’s very disappointing for us that we seem to fall foul of the  SFI Agroforestry data layer which was introduced at it’s introduction (Defra loves a map!). I don’t recall this ever being part of the discussion before but now we find all of our current orchards fall outside the Low Sensitivity Area, a field over it’s all roses. How this is calculated is beyond me as there are no discernable differences between literally one side of a road and the other?!

What it means for us is that as the BPS is phased out we have literally nothing to replace it with and despite all the best efforts made to do exactly what everyone keeps telling us do. ie. grow sustainably, sell local and improve the environment. If we fall foul of this how many other farmers find themselves in the same or worse situation.

There is talk of the future SFI Agroforestry schemes for medium/high density being introduced through CS and the possibility of applying then, we all thought CS was going to die a death but apparently not? Our experience of CS with woodland grants any many other aspects is a deeply frustrating one.

As things stand the Low tier payments decreased from what was discussed and the capital costs look uneven for trees compared to guarding for our type of application, I expect Medium and Higher tiers to follow suit, if they ever make the light of day.

Small farms can’t afford to pay Agents to fill out the forms and have to do it themselves and the process just gets more difficult, despite the promises that SFI would be a new dawn with simpler applications and more manageable processes. It’s debatable whether it’s worth all the effort for the small payments even if we were elligible, maybe we’re better off not getting involved and carry on independantly doing our own thing?

In summary it would be good to think that the current agroforestry layout will be subject to some common sense and reform but based on recent history maybe not. The recently reported DEFRA underspend and the apparent lack of understanding of agriculture from today’s politicians and government in general doesn’t inspire confidence.

Nut Rollers

We have always used nut rollers (or Nut Brooms for some) to harvest places a low canopy or small number of trees or where it’s simply too far to take machinery.

In the past there were products of good quality available in the UK, unfortunately that’s no longer the case so we now import German made ones by Feucht Obsttechnik, made by disabled workers.

These are strong and can be filled properly before emptying, the cheap ones look the same but the wires are thinner and fater a third full nuts fall out when trying to add more.

Two versions for walnuts are available, same roller but with either a wooden handle or a telescopic one. They are priced at £69.99 & £79.99 and can be collected from the farm or we can send by carrier. Contact us for more details.

PDF Flier

Commercial Walnut Growing Courses

Dates for the next 3 courses have been published on Eventbrite, as before we have funding from the Cotswold National Landscape (formerly AONB) for residents or those working within it.

If you are outside our AONB then you can still attend but contact me first please.

July 22nd 2024, October 28th 2024 & 10th March 2025

https://www.eventbrite.co.uk/e/growing-english-walnuts-for-profit-in-the-cotswold-national-landscape-tickets-892933707757?aff=oddtdtcreator

Walnuts and frost

One of the biggest dangers to walnuts is spring frost especially in our Northern European climate, cultivars can break bud from mid-March (very early) through to mid-May (very late) so it’s critical to select the cultivars appropriate to your microclimate.  If you rarely have frosts after early March you’re very lucky and have an enormous choice, most of us don’t.

Spring frost damage takes place once buds have started to break and the bud scales have fallen off, any broken bud, leaf or flower will suffer with any kind of air frost, blacken and fall off.  The good news is that walnuts will reshoot from a lower bud fairly easily.

The difficulty with selecting cultivars is that there is very little reliable information and often what there is has been plagiarised from countless other sources and almost all of it from other countries, so whilst it can be useful it is often not specific to our climate.

Cultivars can be advertised as very cold hardy, meaning in continental climates the trees ability to withstand winter cold temperatures without trunks splitting or dormant buds being damaged when dormant, it does not translate to spring frost resistance!

No Juglans will take spring frost to new foliage.

Below are photos of various Juglans and the damage (or lack of).

Heartnut

Seedling Heartnut – slight damage to a few leaves but generally unaffacted, most trees in the part of the orchard were completely unaffacted.

Grafted Butternut – No damage at all

Heartnut Jewelbox – The only other heartnut affected, a few leaves again but the flowers were not touched.

Walnut Perushtinski – Near the lower part of the orchard and one of the earliest into leaf, probably the most damage but nothing it won’t recover from, young leaves like this are the most vulnerable along with catkins.

Hican Marquardt – all the Carya cultivars and species seem to be less susceptible to mild frost, harder frost (below -1C?) will still damage them though.

Mail order changes

Due to changes from Fedex/TNT on 1st March 2024 we can no longer ship larger trees, we are now limited to a maximum length of 1.2m before getting hit by a very large surchage.

In reality this means all the main crop bare-root trees will be collection only in the winter, the smaller bare-root specialist walnuts and pot grown Carya should still be transportable.

Flowering has started early

The very mild wet winter with no really cold frosts (-5C Lowest) has meant a much earlier bud break and flowering start, 10-14 days depending on cultivar. This is true of all the different walnut species (including the Carya) and pretty much every Heartnut has juvenile leaves already, we’re praying no frosts now but realistically we need to get to mid May here to relax. The very latest cultivars like Fernor have just started loosening their outer bud scales about a week early.

It’s too early to say what effect the wettest winter in maybe 100+ years will have apart from killing a few trees in marginal positions, a bit more blight possibly if we get a very dry summer again, which for us on our mostly acidic old pasture seems to be an issue in some parts of the orchard.

The 1st picture below is of the heavy male catkins developing on walnut Jupiter already, these will probably start dropping pollen in 2-3 weeks maximum, they won’t be the earliest but it is one of the heaviest and most reliable of our main crop pollinators, better than Broadview which seems more sensitive if there are any frosts around.

The second image is of walnut Sychrov’s female and male flowers, this is always the earliest to bud break and set pollen and unfortunately 4 out of 5 years gets frosted, of the main crop walnuts Saturn is probably the next which is why we took out 35 trees and only left 15.

Grafting time

Grafting this year with smaller rootstocks which isn’t as flexible, last year I had many that were 20-25mm diameter in the 100mm above the root line. However the first 100 or so are in the hot-pipe bench and it’s up to temperature so fingers crossed.

This year I managed to get a lot of scion wood from Upton Wold courtesy of My Ian Bond, hopefully this will add to the list of Juglans with cultivars of Cinerea, Ailantifolia, Regia and Nigra.

Of particular interest are two late Regia pollinators, Cyril from the Netherlands which is very late and Corne de Perigord from France which we think will be important for us in the future to ensure pollination of late flowerers like Fernor.

The other we’d like to graft is Ronde de Montignac, next month I hope.